What powertrain to select when adding new mining trucks to an underground operation?
A powertrain is, in simple terms, the system within a vehicle that generates and delivers power to make it move. This article uses the terms powertrain and power source interchangeably, as power source is more commonly used in everyday mining language.
How does a powertrain work?
A powertrain typically consists of three main elements: the engine or electric motor, the energy source (such as a fuel tank or battery pack), and the drivetrain. While conventional powertrains rely on multiple mechanical components to transfer power, electric powertrains typically have simpler drivetrains with fewer moving parts and lower mechanical complexity.
Selecting the best powertrain for a mine truck depends on the specific use case, operating conditions, planning horizon, and sustainability ambitions. There is no single optimal solution for all mines.
- Diesel-powered trucks (diesel-mechanical or diesel-electric) remain the most suitable choice for operations with a short planning horizon due to their low upfront cost, proven technology, and relatively simple infrastructure requirements.
- Diesel-electric trucks offer lower fuel consumption, better performance, and reduced maintenance requirements than diesel-mechanical trucks, often resulting in a lower total cost of ownership (TCO).
- For mines with a longer planning horizon, electrified alternatives become more attractive. Battery-electric trucks eliminate tailpipe emissions and significantly reduce heat generation, improving the working environment and potentially lowering ventilation costs. However, they require substantial upfront investment, charging or battery-swapping infrastructure, and more careful operational planning.
- Trolley-assisted trucks often deliver the lowest TCO on high-production haul ramps over long mine lives. Despite their high initial infrastructure costs, they can enable continuous operation with low running costs.
- Hybrid solutions (diesel-battery) can reduce fuel consumption and emissions, but their effectiveness is highly dependent on the duty cycle and battery size. Fuel cells are neither technically mature nor economically or operationally viable for underground mining in the foreseeable future.
- Ventilation costs, mine depth, temperature, energy prices, CO₂ reduction targets, and mine life are often decisive factors. In many cases, the reduced ventilation requirements associated with electrification can outweigh the higher vehicle and infrastructure costs.
Which power source is best for a mine truck?
There is no simple answer.
The correct answer is: "It depends on the use case and operating conditions."
This article takes an in-depth look at the different power sources available for mining trucks and provides guiding principles for determining which solutions are best suited to different mining applications.
Power sources overview
Advantages and drawbacks of the power sources
Diesel-mechanic
It is often possible to run diesel engines on more environmentally friendly fuels, such as HVO100. This can reduce global CO₂ emissions but comes with a higher fuel cost.
Another alternative is hydrogen combustion engines, which are modified diesel engines. They produce fewer emissions but come with much higher fuel costs and additional risks discussed in the Fuel Cells section below. This is generally not considered a suitable solution for underground mining vehicles.
Here you can find an overview of all available Epiroc diesel-mechanical mining trucks.
Diesel-electric
A truck with a diesel-electric drivetrain is similar in many respects to a diesel-mechanical truck. It is fueled by diesel and produces emissions and heat.
Battery-electric
This is the most common option for achieving a zero-tailpipe-emission mining truck.
Here you can discover all available Epiroc battery-electric mining trucks.
Hybrid
Plug-in hybrid
Plug-in hybrids are common in passenger cars, which are often driven short distances and then parked long enough for charging. Mine trucks operate differently and typically need to run continuously throughout a shift.
Since there is often no opportunity to charge a mine truck during operation, the value of a plug-in hybrid is limited.
Trolley (battery-trolley)
A trolley truck is powered by the trolley system for most of its operation while driving. At the same time, the battery can be charged if needed. When disconnected from the catenary wires, the truck operates on battery power.
At Epiroc, we currently offer one trolley-truck alternative: Minetruck MT42 SG Trolley.
Trolley (diesel-trolley)
Fuel cells
Research into alternative hydrogen storage methods is ongoing, but these technologies are still in early stages and have their own disadvantages.
At present, fuel cells are not considered a suitable solution for underground mining vehicles due to technical, economic, and safety challenges.
Which powertrain to select?
Choosing the right powertrain for your next mining truck requires balancing several factors. Is the planning horizon short or long term? What ventilation requirements does the mine have? Are there environmental targets or site-specific constraints that need to be considered? The answers to these questions can help identify the most suitable powertrain for your underground operation.
Let's explore these considerations to help make your next mining truck selection more informed.
Short planning horizon
When a fast return on investment is required due to a short remaining mine life or short-term contractor agreements, diesel-powered trucks are generally the natural choice. Whether diesel-mechanical or diesel-electric is the better option depends on many variables affecting TCO; however, diesel-electric is often the more efficient alternative.
A prerequisite for diesel power is that the ventilation system can handle exhaust gases and heat from the engines.
Long planning horizon
If the planning horizon is equal to or longer than the expected lifetime of the trucks, alternative power sources should be considered.
If diesel power is required, diesel-electric is often the preferred option. The higher truck cost can be offset by improved productivity and reduced fuel consumption.
Battery-powered trucks have higher CAPEX or OPEX (depending on how the battery is financed). They also require charging installations. However, savings from reduced ventilation requirements, sometimes including ventilation-air cooling, and improved air quality can justify the higher direct costs. Environmental targets and CO₂ taxes may further strengthen the business case.
For operations with a long planning horizon and high production volumes on the same ramp, trolley trucks often provide the lowest TCO. The initial investment is high, but operating costs are substantially lower than diesel or battery-only alternatives.
Ventilation challenges
Ventilation is a major cost and operational challenge in underground mining. Diesel engine emissions are one of the primary drivers of ventilation demand. In some underground mines, high ambient temperatures also require cooling, which consumes significant amounts of energy.
The cost savings associated with reduced ventilation requirements, including fewer fans, shafts, ventilation ducts, energy consumption, and cooling, can sometimes exceed the additional investment required for battery-powered or trolley-powered trucks.
However, switching from diesel to electric does not always generate ventilation savings. Ventilation is also required to remove blast gases, which can be the dominant ventilation driver. In these cases, savings may come only from reduced power consumption, although these savings can still be substantial.
The best opportunities for ventilation-related savings from electric mining trucks include:
- Greenfield projects: New mines or major extensions where ventilation can be designed around electric equipment from the start.
- Mine expansions: Situations where the existing ventilation infrastructure has reached its practical limit and where further expansion would otherwise require major investment.
Both diesel-electric and diesel-battery hybrids reduce ventilation requirements slightly compared to diesel-mechanical trucks due to lower exhaust emissions, but the reduction is typically not substantial.
Fuel cells do not produce hazardous emissions, but they do generate heat. They also have challenges operating in high ambient temperatures, making them less suitable where ventilation is primarily needed for cooling.
High sustainability ambitions
Strong sustainability ambitions can be a major driver for electric trucks and other electric equipment. The challenge is often balancing ambitious CO₂ targets with economic realities when selecting a specific truck technology.
Diesel-electric trucks and diesel-battery hybrids can serve as stepping stones toward reduced emissions. While they may not meet long-term 2040 or 2050 targets on their own, they can contribute significantly to achieving nearer-term goals, such as 2030 targets.